Skip to main content
All posts

What is the difference between a 2x2:2 AP and a 4x4:4 AP?

François Vergès, CWNE #1805 min read

I get this question a lot in the field.

It rarely comes out that way, though. Usually it sounds like: "Should I get this AP or that one?" "Will the high density model help me?" "Do I really need the high-end AP in my environment?"

Underneath all of these questions is often the same one: what is the real difference between a 2x2:2 and a 4x4:4 access point?

The main difference between the top-tier APs and the lower-tier APs is usually the number of spatial streams supported. Today, we typically see 2x2:2 APs on the lower end and 4x4:4 APs on the higher end.

The Two Misconceptions

Before looking at what is actually happening, here are the two assumptions I hear the most:

  • A 4x4:4 AP provides double the capacity compared to a 2x2:2 AP
  • Client devices go twice as fast when they connect to a 4x4:4 AP instead of a 2x2:2 AP

Neither one is true. Here is why.

It Starts With the Clients

The piece that is almost always left out of the conversation is the client device.

The capabilities of the AP and the capabilities of the client together drive the speed at which they communicate over the air.

To keep things simple, let us consider that most modern clients are 2x2:2. They have 2 antennas and can achieve a 2 spatial stream MIMO communication. This is true, by the way: most of the Wi-Fi clients you will find in the enterprise space today are 2x2:2.

Now let us take two APs:

  • AP-1: a 2x2:2 access point
  • AP-2: a 4x4:4 access point

Regardless of which one the client connects to, the communication is capped by the lowest common denominator. In our case, that is 2 spatial streams.

So what is the advantage of using a 4x4:4 AP then? There are actually two main advantages, and both come from properties of MIMO: the ability to use multiple antennas to transmit and receive.

Advantage 1: The AP Hears the Client Better (MRC)

The first advantage of having more antennas on the AP is the ability to better hear what the clients have to say.

A 4x4:4 AP uses its additional antennas to better decode incoming signals. The technology is called MRC (Maximum Ratio Combining). It combines the copies of the signal received on all 4 antennas before decoding them, which increases the receive SNR and gives the AP a cleaner copy of the same transmission.

Think about it this way: it is still a 2 spatial stream signal being sent, but it is received by 4 antennas working together.

That better SNR allows the AP to use higher modulation, which raises the uplink data rates. In the field, I see this translate into a 10% to 15% improvement on the uplink. A real gain, but nowhere near a doubling.

The benefits show up in three places:

  • Higher uplink data rates from the same client
  • Less airtime consumed per transmission, which increases the capacity of the cell
  • Fewer retries, because frames are decoded correctly more often

To me, this is the main advantage of deploying 4x4:4 APs.

Advantage 2: The AP Transmits Smarter (Tx Beamforming)

The AP can also use its extra antennas to optimize its own transmissions.

The MIMO technology called Transmit Beamforming allows the AP to adjust how it sends signals across its antennas so that the signal arrives at the client with a better SNR, which can improve the downlink.

Once again here, you can expect to see a 10% to 15% improvement; this time on the downlink.

One clarification on those numbers: these two gains apply to different directions of the same conversation, so they do not stack into a 30% improvement, and they never turn into the 2x that people expect. Each direction simply gets a little more efficient.

How I Decide in the Field

If you are deploying in an environment where you expect a high number of connected clients, go with the 4x4:4 AP. It will be as optimized as possible and will give you the best results under load. These higher-end APs will also have better hardware that can help them better perform under heavy load. The RF will be more robust.

If capacity is not your strongest requirement and you have less demanding requirements, you can build a perfectly working Wi-Fi network with 2x2:2 APs.

One last thing to keep in mind: some features only ship on selected high-end models, so you may end up buying a 4x4:4 AP not for the spatial streams but for a dedicated scanning radio, IoT radios, multi-gig or multiple Ethernet ports, or external antenna options. Always check the datasheet before deciding based on streams alone.

Resources

If you want to go deeper on this topic, here are two talks I recommend:

Tell us your problem

Running into this on your own network?

Describe the environment and the requirements. We will tell you honestly whether we are the right fit and what our approach would be.

One of our Wi-Fi experts reads every message.